This past week, I was introduced to the activity 'skyscrapers' which is demonstrated in the picture below. Our facilitator asked us to get into groups of about four individuals, handed out some math-link cubes, and briefly explained how this activity worked.
At first, we were all very confused and could not seem to understand the instructions. We could not figure out how this activity worked and even began saying things like “this is impossible”. I found myself feeling discouraged because I could not figure out how to complete the activity. Instead of giving up, we pushed through the phase of being discouraged and we began thinking of other ways that this activity may be solved. Without realizing it at the time, we used many strategies to try to find the answer. For example, we discussed other possible options, tried to make connections to our prior knowledge, reasoned with each other, and used representations to show our peers our ideas. I realize now that we were all using the mathematical processes in order to solve this problem.
Earlier in the class, we discussed the seven mathematical processes. As outlined in the Ontario Mathematics Curriculum, the mathematical processes are problem solving, reasoning and proving, reflecting, selecting tools and computational strategies, connecting, representation, and communication. After completing this activity, it is evident that most, if not all, of these processes allowed our group to find the correct way to solve this problem. Since we had found the answer ourselves, we were excited to complete the activity and moved onto the more difficult problems. As I reflect on this experience, I can see the importance of allowing students to work through problems without providing them with step by step instructions. For example, if we were told exactly how to solve this activity, I believe we would not have been as excited to find the correct way to solve the problem.
Hi Laura,
ReplyDeleteAs someone who appreciates the concept of inquiry-based learning in classrooms, I thoroughly enjoyed your post. At the beginning of the exercise my group was also rather confused by the lack of step by step instructions but as I now reflect on my own experience, I agree that I may not have been so excited about solving the problem if I had been told how to do it. I believe that when educators encourage students to follow rigid steps and memorize formulas that they are robbing them of that wonderful "aha!" moment that many groups were able to experience when completing this problem. I also really enjoyed when you mentioned your intention to celebrate the differences in your students and I agree that we, as educators, should be encouraging everyone to think outside the box.
I look forward to reading more of your reflections!
Shannon